Peer Benchmarking Shows a Practice Owner What the Collections Swing Should Look Like

SpieglerBlevins works with dental and medical practice owners across the Tri-Cities who see the same pattern every year, in which collections rise through November and December and then soften in January. Much of the movement follows the insurance calendar, because many patients schedule treatment before their annual dental benefit maximums and medical deductibles reset with the new plan year. A practice owner viewing a single month in isolation cannot tell whether a strong December reflects that seasonal pattern or a genuine change in the practice. Peer benchmarking supplies the comparison that separates the two, which is why the firm includes it in its advisory work for dental and medical practices.

Why do practice collections swing at year end?

SpieglerBlevins attributes most of the year-end swing to the timing of insurance benefits rather than to any underlying change in patient demand. Patients who have unused annual benefits, or who have already met a deductible, have a financial reason to complete treatment before the plan year closes, so production concentrates in the final weeks of the year. Collections then lag production by the time insurers take to pay claims, which carries part of the December activity into January deposits. The result is a pattern in which production, collections and cash in the bank each peak at a different point, and an owner reading only the bank balance sees none of the three clearly. Our team can advise you on how to read production, collections and deposits as separate measures in the monthly financial statements.

What does peer benchmarking show that a profit and loss statement does not?

SpieglerBlevins uses peer benchmarking to compare a practice’s figures with those of practices of similar type, size and payer mix, drawing on published sector surveys for dental and medical practices. A profit and loss statement reports what the practice earned and spent, but it cannot indicate whether a staffing cost, a collection rate or a supply cost is typical for a practice of that kind. Benchmarking supplies that context, so an owner can judge whether a December surge is larger or smaller than practices of similar type and size usually experience. The comparison is credible in dental and medical work because those sectors publish data on these measures, which is not true of most small business sectors. Our team includes benchmarking in its advisory work for the dental and medical practices it serves on a recurring engagement.

Published surveys carry a limitation the firm states plainly to every client, which is that a survey sample may not resemble a solo or two-dentist practice in Washington County or Sullivan County. A practice in this region often differs from a large metropolitan group practice in payer mix, cost base and labor market, so the firm adjusts the comparison rather than quoting a survey median. The value of benchmarking lies in the direction and size of a variance rather than in matching a national figure exactly. We can advise you on which peer comparisons are meaningful for a practice of your size, structure and location in the region.

Which measures should a practice owner track through year end?

SpieglerBlevins tracks a short set of measures with practice owners during November, December and January, because these are the months in which the swing distorts the picture most. Each measure is compared with the same month of the prior year and with a peer range rather than with the previous month alone. The five measures below are written for dental practices, and they adapt readily to medical practices with minor changes in terminology.

  1. Gross production by provider shows whether the year-end increase is spread across the practice or concentrated in a single schedule.
  2. The collection rate, measured as collections against net production, shows whether the increase in activity is converting to cash at the normal pace.
  3. Accounts receivable aged beyond 60 days shows whether December claims are being paid or are accumulating into a January problem.
  4. Staff costs as a share of collections show whether the added hours worked during the busy weeks remain proportionate to the revenue they produce.
  5. Supply costs as a share of production show whether purchasing has accelerated faster than the treatment volume it supports.

None of these measures requires new software, although each requires books closed accurately every month, because a figure assembled once a year cannot be compared month by month. The comparison with the prior year matters more than any single figure, because it shows whether the practice is moving toward or away from its peers. Our team prepares these measures for practices on a recurring engagement as part of the monthly financial statement package it delivers.

How should a practice plan for the January softening?

SpieglerBlevins plans for January with practice owners during November, while the December surge can still be directed toward the practice’s priorities. A practice expecting lower January deposits can time an equipment payment, a retirement plan contribution or an owner distribution against the cash it will actually hold rather than the December balance. The same planning identifies whether year-end purchases belong in 2026 or 2027, a decision the firm addressed in its October article on equipment placed in service by Dec. 31. Practices with current monthly financial statements complete this planning in a single business planning discussion, because the figures already exist. We can advise you on how the year-end pattern affects the practice’s cash position into the first months of the new year.

Why does benchmarking depend on monthly books?

SpieglerBlevins includes benchmarking only where the underlying books are current, because a comparison built on incomplete figures misleads more than it informs. A practice whose bookkeeping is completed once a year, shortly before the return is due, has no reliable November figure to compare with anyone. The monthly close produces the consistent, categorized figures that benchmarking requires, and it produces them while the year can still be influenced. Benchmarking is therefore a result of the recurring engagement rather than a standalone report, and it is most useful to owners who already receive monthly financial statements. Our team provides benchmarking within its advisory work for dental and medical practices on a recurring engagement, alongside the monthly statements.

Frequently asked questions

Why are dental practice collections higher in December?

Many patients schedule treatment before their annual benefit maximums reset with the new plan year, which concentrates production in the final weeks of the year. Collections follow production after the time insurers take to pay, so part of the December activity arrives in January deposits.

What is peer benchmarking for a dental practice?

Peer benchmarking compares a practice’s financial measures, such as its collection rate, staff costs and supply costs, with published figures for practices of similar type and size. The comparison indicates whether a figure is typical for a practice of that kind, which a profit and loss statement alone cannot show.

Does SpieglerBlevins prepare benchmarking for practices that are not clients?

SpieglerBlevins provides peer benchmarking within its advisory work for dental and medical practices on a recurring engagement, because the comparison depends on books closed accurately every month. The firm does not prepare benchmarking reports or review a practice’s figures before an engagement begins, because the comparison would rest on books the firm has not maintained.

How should a practice handle a year-end collections swing?

A practice handles the swing best by planning its January commitments against projected deposits rather than against the December bank balance. Monthly financial statements that separate production, collections and receivables make that planning possible in November, while the decisions remain open, rather than in February.

Contact us to discuss any questions you may have.

The information provided in this blog post is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be financial, legal, or professional advice. Readers should not construe any information in this blog post as financial advice from our firm. Our firm provides this information with no representations or warranties, express or implied. Before making any financial decisions or taking any actions, seek the advice of qualified financial, legal, or professional advisors who understand your individual situation.